Cost Optimization · Jun 17, 2025 · 3 min read

Having a procurement team is not the same as having procurement

Most mid-market companies with a procurement function still buy their largest indirect categories without it. The gap is not people. It is mandate.

Part of Software, cloud and renewals

Having a procurement team does not mean the company has procurement over its biggest contracts. In most mid-market businesses the team runs direct spend well and never touches the agency contract, the software enterprise agreement or the cloud commitment. Closing that gap takes a mandate from the CFO, not more headcount.

Where does procurement usually stop?

"We have procurement." We hear that in almost every early conversation with a mid-market company. It is usually true, and usually beside the point.

The team exists. It processes purchase orders, onboards suppliers and runs the categories it was built for. It is not in the room when the agency contract renews, when the software agreement gets signed, or when the cloud commitment gets locked in for another year.

Those three are, in most businesses we look at, among the largest spending lines outside cost of goods. They get bought by the function that uses them, negotiated by someone who does it once every year or two, against a vendor whose whole job is negotiating that exact contract every day. Not a fair fight.

How does the gap form?

Mid-market procurement usually grows up around direct spend: materials, equipment, logistics. Those are the categories where a formal process was obviously needed from day one.

Marketing, technology and professional services get treated differently. Specialist. Relationship-driven. Too time-sensitive for a process. So they stay outside it for years, and the process never expands to follow the money.

Nobody is being unreasonable. Marketing wants to move fast on a campaign. The CTO doesn't want procurement slowing a platform decision. Finance is watching cash, not category strategy. Each choice makes sense. The result is that the categories with the most money and the least governance have no commercial owner at all.

Vendors notice. A seller knows when the buyer across the table is a specialist and when it is a marketing director doing an annual renewal, and the pricing reflects it.

What closes the gap?

Not a bigger procurement team. More headcount with the same narrow mandate gives you more people doing the same narrow job.

It takes a mandate change, and it has to come from the CFO, because every function that has bought its own vendors for years will push back. The mandate needs three parts:

For agency spend in particular, the same logic applies to the roster itself. See fewer agencies, more senior people. More on renewal timing sits under software renewals.

What is the test for this quarter?

Take your ten largest vendor contracts outside direct materials. For each one, write down who owns it commercially, when it next renews, and when it was last benchmarked.

ContractCommercial ownerNext renewalLast benchmarked
Media agency
Largest software agreement
Cloud commitment
IT managed services
Next six by spend

If more than a couple of answers are "not sure" or "whoever's been handling it," you have confirmed the gap and you know where to start.

The next step

Fill in that table this week, then write a one-paragraph mandate for the CFO to sign: the threshold, who benchmarks above it, and the 90-day renewal alert. It is a governance change, not an org chart change, and one of the cheapest high-return decisions a CFO can make. If nobody internally can own the calendar yet, our Renewal Desk runs it on a retainer.

Common questions
Why doesn't having a procurement team mean a company has procurement?

Because the team often never touches the largest indirect categories, such as agency contracts, software agreements and cloud commitments. Those are bought directly by the function that uses them, outside the procurement process.

What is the risk of leaving those contracts outside procurement?

They are negotiated by someone who does it once every year or two, against a vendor who negotiates that contract every day, and many renew automatically with no negotiation at all.

What closes the procurement gap?

A mandate change from the CFO with three parts: a spending threshold above which contracts must be benchmarked, category expertise for the largest lines, and a renewal calendar that surfaces contracts 90 days before they lock in.

Get the next one

Practical notes on agencies, media, software and vendor cost.

One useful piece at a time, no fluff. Free on Substack, unsubscribe any time.

Subscribe
A good next step

We would rather look at your numbers than talk about ours. If the largest contracts in the business are signed outside procurement, we can build the mandate and run the first cycle.

Book 15 minutesOr send us a note