Marketing Procurement · Jan 22, 2026 · 3 min read

The agency RFP most brands get wrong, and how to fix it

Most agency RFPs select for whoever writes the best response. Fix the brief, set the scoring before it goes out, and replace the final pitch with real work.

Part of Agency reviews and contracts

Most agency RFPs claim to select for capability but end up selecting for writing. The fix is a short brief that names the real business problem, scoring weights agreed before anything goes out, and a final round built on a working session instead of a second polished presentation.

Why do agency RFPs go wrong?

Agencies spend weeks producing a response built to impress a committee that hasn't agreed what impressive means. The polished deck wins. Or the familiar name. Or the agency whose new business lead built the best rapport. None of those tells you whether the team can do the work.

It isn't cheap for anyone. A 2025 EACA survey of 412 European agencies put the average cost of a new business pitch at about €43,800, with teams of five to eight people each putting in more than 44 hours. Agencies recover that cost somewhere, and usually it is in fees.

When an agency hire goes wrong inside two quarters, the fault line was almost always visible at the RFP stage. It starts with the brief.

What makes a good RFP brief?

The brief is the most important document in the process and usually the weakest. Too long. Plenty of company history, no clear problem. Objectives that could belong to anyone ("drive awareness, grow consideration, convert customers"). Requests for general case studies instead of proof in a comparable situation.

Agencies answer what they are given. A vague brief gets filled with whatever makes the agency look strongest on paper. You learn about their pitch craft, not their fit.

A good brief passes four tests:

For a media review, our note on writing the brief first applies the same tests.

When should you set the scoring?

Before you send. Most teams write the brief first and work out scoring later, sometimes after responses land. Then the committee reverse-engineers weights to fit the agency it already likes.

Agree in writing what you are buying (strategy, creative quality, operating capacity, price, chemistry) and the weight on each. Get sign-off from whoever owns the final decision. Put the person who will run the relationship day to day in the scoring room. A process run only by procurement and legal optimizes for contract terms and misses whether anyone can do the work. A process run only by marketing optimizes for chemistry and misses the commercial terms.

Chemistry belongs on the scorecard. Weight it openly. The mistake is letting it stand in for judging the work.

How many stages should it have?

Two. A written round to get to three finalists, then a working session. Give the finalists a real, current problem and a couple of days. Watching a team think under real constraints tells you more than any rehearsed deck, and it costs the agencies less than a full creative pitch. Insist that the people who would run your account are the ones in that session. We cover why in The agency pitch is theater.

Keep the long list short. Asking eight agencies for full responses wastes their money and your evaluation time, and the best agencies increasingly decline processes that look like that.

What to do Monday

An agency that wins on a sharp, honest brief and then underdelivers has no excuses left. An agency that wins on a vague one always has somewhere to point.

If a brief is about to go out, have someone outside the process read it against those four tests first. That is a short second opinion. If the review is of an agency you already have, start with an agency health check. Our agency review notes cover the rest of the process.

Sources: LBB, EACA calls time on unsustainable agency model (June 2025).

Common questions
What is wrong with the typical agency RFP?

It claims to test capability but mostly rewards whoever writes the most polished response, judged by a committee that often hasn't agreed what it is buying.

What makes a good agency RFP brief?

It names the real business tension, defines success in measurable terms, scopes the work tightly enough to compare responses, and is short enough for senior agency people to read themselves.

How much does pitching cost agencies?

A 2025 EACA survey of 412 European agencies put the average new business pitch at about €43,800, with five to eight staff each spending more than 44 hours.

How should agency selection be structured?

Fix scoring weights before the brief goes out, use a written round to reach three finalists, then run a working session on a live problem instead of a second rehearsed pitch.

Get the next one

Practical notes on agencies, media, software and vendor cost.

One useful piece at a time, no fluff. Free on Substack, unsubscribe any time.

Subscribe
A good next step

We would rather look at your numbers than talk about ours. Fifteen minutes is enough for us to tell you whether your agency terms are worth reopening before 2027 budgets lock.

Book 15 minutesOr send us a note