Taking control of the programmatic supply chain.
A national automotive brand with strong agency partners wanted institutional knowledge and control over where its digital media money went, what it bought, and who owned the data.
Situation
Digital media ran across two agencies, an agency trading desk, and a long list of ad networks. Most insertion orders showed a net cost and no CPM, impression count, or site list. Some reporting listed vendor domains in place of the sites ads ran on. The agencies were good. The governance around them was thin.
What we did
We reviewed insertion orders and planning documents for 16 media vendors, more than $8.5M of digital spend. The gaps were concrete. One video takeover bought on a completed-view basis worked out to a $230 CPM, against $38 for a similar unit elsewhere on the plan. Engagement-priced units equated to about a $44 CPM, where comparable open-market inventory ran roughly $7 to $15. YouTube CPMs ranged from $12 to $83. The trading desk carried a 20% management fee plus a 5% to 6% technology fee. We ran independent site-level reporting, reviewed blacklists and verification, and showed why screenshots and blacklists could not protect the spend. We drafted a log-file data ownership clause and a contract template covering supply-chain fee disclosure, data access, and audit rights, and set out a measurement path for a purchase that closes offline at a dealer.
Outcome
Six recommended actions: buy fewer, better publishers through one DSP; put one third-party verification standard across all agencies; collect log files across the supply chain; map the customer journey in a data platform; prioritize inventory that shifts undecided buyers; and keep the agency scope current. The result was a framework for a deeper conversation with the agencies and vendors, backed by evidence and contract language.
Facing something similar?
Fifteen minutes. We’ll tell you whether the pattern matches and what we’d do first.