What a good fifteen-minute first call with an advisor sounds like
A first call should end with a clear yes or no. What to bring, what a good advisor asks, and the red flags that mean the call didn't do its job.
A good fifteen-minute first call ends with a straight answer: either the problem is one the advisor solves, with a rough view of scope, timing and a small first step, or it isn't, and you hear that on the call. If you hang up with "we'll send something over" and no view of the work, the call didn't do its job.
That is the standard we hold our own first calls to. We start with one question, what isn't working, and use the time to decide two things fast: whether the problem is one we solve, and whether the way we work fits the situation. Often the honest answer is no, and we say so before anyone writes a proposal.
What should you bring?
Four things make fifteen minutes enough:
- The cost line or number that bothers you, with a rough annual figure. "Agency fees, about this much a year" beats "marketing feels expensive."
- The next date that matters. A renewal, a budget deadline, a close, a board meeting.
- Who owns it today, even if the honest answer is nobody.
- What has already been tried, and why it didn't stick.
You don't need a deck, a data pack or a brief. If those exist, they help later.
What a good advisor listens for
We have been on every end of this call: buying consulting, being benchmarked as a vendor, working as operators inside portfolio companies. The useful signals sound like this:
- "We spend a lot on this and nobody is sure what we get." A cost line that grew faster than the governance around it.
- "The number is fine, probably." A metric leadership sees every month and doesn't fully trust.
- "That contract predates everyone here." A vendor, agency or platform nobody has looked at commercially in years, because it kept renewing.
- "We close in six weeks." A deal, a hundred-day plan or an exit with an operational gap in it.
- "We don't need another deck." A team that wants the work done, not described.
Two or three of those in one call and the starting point is usually clear.
What you should be asked
Short questions. Who owns the number? When did someone last benchmark it? What happens if nothing changes for a year? What data could you pull together in a week?
The answers tell an advisor more than any brief. They also tell you something: if nobody in the business can answer them, that is usually the first finding, whoever you end up working with.
What should you leave with?
A yes or no, given on the call. If yes, a clear view of the work: scope, timeline, what access is needed and how it would be priced. And a first step that is deliberately small, such as a fixed-fee four-week Diagnostic, a Second Opinion on one contract, or a single renewal. You should see how the firm works before you commit to more.
If no, a good advisor tells you who is a better fit.
Red flags on any first call
- A deck before any questions. The firm is selling a solution before it knows the problem.
- A paid discovery phase just to decide whether your problem fits. A firm that has seen the pattern can tell you in the first conversation.
- No willingness to say no. If every problem is a fit, none of them are.
- A follow-up drip. Persistence is not a substitute for a clear answer.
Before you book any call
Write two lines: the cost or number that bothers you, and what it costs the business if it doesn't change for a year. If the advisor can't engage with those two lines in fifteen minutes, keep looking.
What happens on a first call with Eighty Twenty?
We ask one question, what isn't working, and use fifteen minutes to decide whether it is a problem we solve and whether our way of working fits. If it isn't a fit, we say so on the call.
What should you prepare for a first call with a consultant?
The cost line or number that bothers you with a rough annual figure, the next date that matters, who owns it today and what has already been tried. A deck isn't needed.
What should you get back from a first consulting call?
A clear yes or no, given during the call. If yes, a view of scope, timeline, access and pricing, plus a small first step such as a fixed-fee diagnostic.
What is a red flag in a consulting firm's first conversation?
A deck before any questions, a paid discovery phase just to decide whether your problem fits, or a firm that never says no.
Practical notes on agencies, media, software and vendor cost.
One useful piece at a time, no fluff. Free on Substack, unsubscribe any time.
SubscribeFinding value a business did not know it had is the part of this work we enjoy most. Fifteen minutes. Tell us what is not working.