Industry Focus · May 20, 2026 · 4 min read

The vendor risk review nobody prices as a cost

In regulated financial services a small marketing or SaaS tool can take months to clear third-party risk review. How to price the delay and tier the queue.

In regulated financial services, the third-party risk review often costs more than the tool it gates, because every month a low-risk tool waits is a month of its return forgone. Nobody puts that delay on the P&L. US regulators already allow proportionate review, so the fix is risk tiering with time targets, not weaker controls.

Why does a small tool take so long to clear?

A marketing team at a bank wants a new attribution tool. Nothing exotic: plenty of other industries adopt it without a second thought.

The contract might clear procurement in a week. The risk review is another matter: security questionnaires, data flow diagrams, SOC 2 review, legal redlines on liability and data residency, compliance sign-off, and sometimes a model risk review if the tool looks anything like a decision engine. Months is common. Anything touching customer data takes longer.

None of that appears as a line item. Executives price the tool. They almost never price the review.

Is the review the problem?

No. Banks and asset managers answer to regulators who care, correctly, about data security, model risk, concentration and operational resilience. The review is not going away.

The problem is that it gets treated as a compliance cost with no ceiling and no owner, rather than an input to a business decision. The team that needs the tool can't see how long the review will take, has no say in its priority, and has no idea what waiting costs. So the tool waits behind whatever arrived first, and six months later someone asks why the campaign never launched. This is not a small-bank problem. It is what happens when a control built for the riskiest relationships (core banking, payment processors, cloud infrastructure) gets applied at roughly the same intensity to every vendor. We cover the cost side of the same function in Bank vendor spend beyond the core.

How do you price the delay?

Put a monthly value on the tool before it enters the queue, then multiply by the months it waits. As an illustration only: a tool expected to return $40,000 a month that waits six months has cost $240,000 before anyone logs in.

That number belongs in vendor selection next to price and terms. A tool with fewer features and a lighter data footprint that clears in three weeks can be worth more than a better tool that takes eight months. Most processes can't compare those honestly, because the review timeline sits in another department's queue. The same discipline applies to the software stack as a whole, as our piece on SaaS stack rationalization and our IT and software cost work set out.

Do regulators allow lighter review for low-risk vendors?

Yes. The 2023 interagency guidance on third-party relationships asks for due diligence "commensurate with the level of risk and complexity" of each relationship. On model risk, the Federal Reserve, OCC and FDIC issued SR 26-2 in April 2026, replacing SR 11-7 with a risk-based approach under which oversight of a low-risk, immaterial model can be limited to identification and performance monitoring. Generative and agentic AI sit outside its scope for now, with banks told to rely on their broader risk management while the agencies gather input.

So the permission exists. What is missing is routing.

TierExampleReview pathTarget time (our rule of thumb)
LowMarketing analytics on aggregated, non-customer data; AI that drafts ad copyStandard security questionnaire, contract checkWeeks
MediumTools touching customer contact data or internal systemsFull security review, data flow mapping, legalOne to three months
HighCore systems, payments, models influencing credit or underwritingFull third-party and model risk review, ongoing monitoringAs long as it takes

Why is AI hitting the same bottleneck harder?

An AI tool for marketing or customer service often gets a model risk review layered on top of the vendor review. That scrutiny is right for a model that influences a credit decision. For a model that drafts ad copy, it sends low-risk AI down the slowest path by default, while competitors outside financial services ship in weeks.

The institutions handling this well are not skipping governance. They separate "helps draft copy" from "influences a lending decision" and build a path proportionate to each. More on budgeting for AI tools sits under AI search and spend.

Next step: measure review time by tier

Pull the last 12 months of vendor review requests, group them by risk tier, and calculate the median days from request to approval for each. If low-risk tools take as long as medium-risk ones, the queue is not tiered, whatever the policy says. Our financial services work starts from that table.

Sources: Federal Register, Interagency Guidance on Third-Party Relationships, June 2023, Federal Reserve, SR 26-2 revised guidance on model risk management, Orrick, agencies overhaul model risk management guidance.

Common questions
Why does a small SaaS tool take months to clear vendor review at a bank?

Third-party risk review runs the same core steps regardless of tool size: security questionnaires, data flow mapping, SOC 2 review, legal redlines and compliance sign-off. Reviews are often queued by order of arrival rather than by risk.

Do US regulators allow lighter review of low-risk vendors and models?

Yes. The 2023 interagency third-party guidance calls for due diligence commensurate with each relationship's risk and complexity, and SR 26-2 (April 2026) lets banks limit oversight of low-risk, immaterial models to identification and performance monitoring.

Does SR 26-2 cover generative AI?

No. Generative and agentic AI models are outside its scope for now. Banks are expected to manage them through their broader risk management and governance practices.

How do you measure the cost of a slow vendor review?

Estimate the tool's monthly value before it enters review and multiply by the months it waits. Track median review time by risk tier so you can see whether low-risk tools are moving faster.

Get the next one

Practical notes on agencies, media, software and vendor cost.

One useful piece at a time, no fluff. Free on Substack, unsubscribe any time.

Subscribe
If this sounded familiar

That is usually the first sign there is money in it. Fifteen minutes. We’ll tell you whether we can help and what it would look like.

Book 15 minutesOr send us a note